Press J to jump to the feed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts
View
29
pinned by moderators
Posted by
Working to make cookies Nutritious
1 year ago
Archived
29
4 comments
6
Moderator of r/nutrition

Welcome to the weekly r/Nutrition feature post for personal circumstance questions and diet evaluation requests. Wondering if you are eating too much of something, not enough of something, or if what you regularly eat has the nutritional content you want or need? Ask here.

Rules for Questions

  • Nutrition related questions about your specific diet may be asked. However, before asking, please remember to check the FAQ first and see if it has already been covered in the subreddit.

  • You MAY NOT ask for advice as to how a nutritional choice would impact a specific medial condition. Consult a professional.

  • If you do not get an answer here, you still may not create a post about it. Not having an answer does not give you an exception to the Personal Nutrition posting rule.

Rules for Responders

  • Support your claims - Where applicable ALL responses should support any claims made by including links to science based evidence / studies / data. Need to find the evidence and track down primary sources? Try looking for information at PubMed or Google Scholar. Other sources of nutrition information can be found at the USDA Food Composition Database, NutritionData, Nutrition Journal, and Nutrition.gov (a service of the National Agricultural Library).

  • Keep it civil - Converse WITH the other person rather than conversing ABOUT the other person. If you disagree about the science, the source(s), or the interpretation(s) then do so civilly. Any personal attacks will be removed and may lead to a ban. Let moderators know of these kinds of issues by using the report button below any comments containing personal attacks.

  • Keep it on topic - This subreddit is for discussion about nutrition. Disparaging commentary about others is off topic. Non-nutritional facets of food are even off topic. Off topic comments will be removed. Let moderators know of these kinds of issues by using the report button below any comments which are off topic.

6
93 comments
110

I’m not a nutritionist myself but have an interest in eating healthy.

I’m super confused - when I do my research on the internet I find just as much evidence supporting each diet - there have been studies saying a vegan diet is the best thing for us, studies saying the same for keto and now this carnivore diet.

How do people get their head around what is actually healthy?

110
166 comments
12

Read this reply in another thread on another sub. How accurate is this? I know people often direct others to websites like Cholesterol Code or YouTube channels with pro-keto/low carb advocates but what is the real science?

How accurate is this statement? Are there any solid/reliable studies that prove or disprove this?

12
5 comments
11

Sorry for the overly long post.

So essentially, I read How Not To Die by Dr. Michael Greger last year and some of the things in that book blew me away. Don't get me wrong, the book is absolute propaganda for a whole foods plant based diet and it has loads of cherry-picked studies so it definitely should not be taken at face value. However, one thing that stood out to me was the research into reversing heart disease with a whole foods plant based diet. Dr. Dean Ornish and Dr. Caldwell Esselstyn are two of the doctors that have successfully stopped or even reversed heart disease from progressing further in their patients through lifestyle and diet intervention.

Here you can see one of Dr. Esselstyn's first studies on this;

Of the 22 participants, 5 dropped out within 2 years, and 17 maintained the diet, 11 of whom completed a mean of 5.5 years of follow-up. All 11 of these participants reduced their cholesterol level from a mean baseline of 246 mg/dL (6.36 mmol/L) to below 150 mg/dL (3.88 mmol/L). Lesion analysis by percent stenosis showed that of 25 lesions, 11 regressed and 14 remained stable. Mean arterial stenosis decreased from 53.4% to 46.2% (estimated decrease = 7%; 95% confidence interval [CI], 3.3 to 10.7, P < .05). Analysis by minimal lumen diameter of 25 lesions found that 6 regressed, 14 remained stable, and 5 progressed. Mean lumen diameter increased from 1.3 mm to 1.4 mm (estimated increase = 0.08 mm; 95% CI, -0.06 to 0.22, P = NS). Disease was clinically arrested in all 11 participants, and none had new infarctions. Among the 11 remaining patients after 10 years, six continued the diet and had no further coronary events, whereas the five dropouts who resumed their prestudy diet reported 10 coronary events.

Here you can see Dr. Ornish's study;

In a prospective, randomised, controlled trial to determine whether comprehensive lifestyle changes affect coronary atherosclerosis after 1 year, 28 patients were assigned to an experimental group (low-fat vegetarian diet, stopping smoking, stress management training, and moderate exercise) and 20 to a usual-care control group. 195 coronary artery lesions were analysed by quantitative coronary angiography. The average percentage diameter stenosis regressed from 40.0 (SD 16.9)% to 37.8 (16.5)% in the experimental group yet progressed from 42.7 (15.5)% to 46.1 (18.5)% in the control group. When only lesions greater than 50% stenosed were analysed, the average percentage diameter stenosis regressed from 61.1 (8.8)% to 55.8 (11.0)% in the experimental group and progressed from 61.7 (9.5)% to 64.4 (16.3)% in the control group. Overall, 82% of experimental-group patients had an average change towards regression. Comprehensive lifestyle changes may be able to bring about regression of even severe coronary atherosclerosis after only 1 year, without use of lipid-lowering drugs.

Yeah I'll admit that the populations are low in both studies but I dont see why the results wouldn't be similar for larger populations, and Dr. Ornish has successfully put thousands of people through his program for Reversing Heart Disease since the study.

A whole foods plant based diet seems to have all the other benefits of diets like Keto, Mediterranean, Paleo etc., such as helping with weight loss, lowering blood pressure, glycemic control in type 2 diabetics, protective effects against cancer, heart disease and all cause mortality and it is suitable for all stages of life, including pregnancy, lactation, infancy, childhood, adolescence, older adulthood, and for athletes according to the American Dietetics Association.

I can't find the exact amount, but here says [1/4 people die to heart disease every year in America](https://www.cdc.gov/heartdisease/facts.htm](https://www.cdc.gov/heartdisease/facts.htm) and the [WHO estimates 31% of people in the world die of heart disease every single year](https://www.who.int/health-topics/cardiovascular-diseases/](https://www.who.int/health-topics/cardiovascular-diseases/) so we can assume these figures are somewhat accurate. How are people not more concerned about the number one killer in the world when in most cases it clearly can be prevented? Why is it that the only diet ever proven to prevent this disease is not the standard recommended diet? Am I missing something?

As you've probably gathered by now, I follow a vegan diet and try my best to eat only whole plant based foods. I want it to be clear that I have not always been vegan, I only went vegan less than a year ago when researching about diet and health. I'm not trying to start an argument, I'm genuinely just trying to start a dialogue.

11
43 comments
53
53
66 comments
2

what are good sources of fats, carbs, and protein for someone looking to switch over from a primarily animal protein based diet?

2
8 comments
3

After moving into my new apartment which doesn't have a kitchen or bathroom, I've found it difficult to stay up and be the healthiest person.

Without cooking, do you think you could maintain your health standards?

3
7 comments

Community Details

588k

Members

323

Online

Nov 17, 2008

Cake Day

A subreddit for the discussion of nutrition science. Macronutrients, micronutrients, vitamins, diets, and nutrition news are among the many topics discussed. Civil discourse is required.

r/nutrition Rules

1.
No Dietary Activism
2.
No Personal Situation / Diet Eval posts
3.
Follow proper Reddiquette
4.
No blogspam or self-promotion
5.
No Requesting or Providing Medical Advice
6.
Links must be direct
7.
No posts from new or neg karma accounts
8.
Remain on Topic

Moderators

u/drpibb
anti-hive mind
u/MidnightSlinks
Moderator, MPH, RD
u/soundeziner
Working to make cookies Nutritious
u/abrownn
Lettuce is a superfood
u/polarism
Moderator
Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.
RedditView is Reddit Online Viewer ,Not Phising ,Not Hacking!